Fans may vote for up to three semifinalist songs. The judging panel then considers audience response alongside craft, originality, and long-term commercial potential.
The strongest songs combine emotional impact, memorability, and the potential to endure as a modern holiday favorite.
Melody, lyric quality, structure, and emotional resonance.
Authentic seasonal identity and festive storytelling.
A fresh point of view with distinctive creative character.
The ability to connect with a broad public audience.
Professional delivery, arrangement, and overall readiness.
Listen to the songs below and vote for the three semifinalists you believe deserve to advance to the finals.
Finalists will be revealed each week as voting concludes.
Hosted by Jason McCoy and featuring all 10 semifinalist songs for the week, with backstories and additional Holiday Classic spotlights.